Your driveway might seem like a “set it and forget it” part of your home, but over time, wear and tear will take its toll. Knowing when to repave — instead of just patching or sealing — can save you thousands in the long run.
At J. Perry Paving, we’ve seen every stage of driveway deterioration. Here are the 5 biggest red flags that it’s time to stop patching and start fresh.
1. Widespread Cracking or “Alligator Cracks”
A few hairline cracks? Not a big deal. But if your driveway looks like a reptile’s back — with deep, interconnected cracks — that’s called “alligator cracking.” It signals serious base damage beneath the surface.
What it means: Seal coating or patching won’t fix it. You’ll need to repave to restore structure and durability.
→ Learn how seal coating can prevent this — if caught early.
2. Potholes and Loose Gravel
Potholes form when moisture penetrates cracks, freezes, and expands — creating cavities. Left untreated, they grow and damage your vehicle and your property’s appearance.
What it means: One pothole might be patchable, but several usually indicate that the driveway’s foundation is compromised.
→ Not sure how bad it is? We offer honest, pressure-free inspections and estimates.
3. Pooling Water or Drainage Problems
Standing water is a major sign that your driveway is no longer sloped or draining correctly. Water weakens the base and leads to deeper damage over time.
What it means: Improper drainage can’t be fixed with surface repairs. It often requires excavation and a complete repave.
4. Crumbling Edges
The edges of your driveway take a beating, especially if they’re unsupported by concrete curbs or landscaping. When they start breaking down, it’s usually a sign the whole surface is nearing the end of its lifespan.
What it means: If the crumbling is isolated, a patch might work. But if the damage is spreading inward, a repave is the smarter solution.
5. Your Driveway is Over 20 Years Old
Even with regular maintenance, most asphalt driveways have a natural life cycle of 20–30 years — shorter if exposed to salt, snowplows, or heavy use.
What it means: If your driveway is approaching this age and showing other signs of wear, it’s time to start planning for replacement.
→ Read: How Long Does a New Driveway Last in New England Weather?
When to Repave vs. Repair
| Condition | Repair | Repave |
| Hairline Cracks | ✔ | — |
| Widespread Cracks | — | ✔ |
| Small Potholes | ✔ | — |
| Drainage Issues | — | ✔ |
| Structural Base Problems | — | ✔ |
Still not sure? We’ll assess your situation honestly and help you decide what’s necessary — no upselling.
Why Homeowners Trust J. Perry Paving
We’ve repaved thousands of driveways across Rhode Island, and our focus is always on long-term value, not quick fixes. When it’s time to repave, we do it right:
- Full removal and base grading
- Thick, durable asphalt with proper compaction
- Drainage planning to avoid future pooling
- Clean edges and optional seal coating
→ See our residential paving services
Final Thoughts
If your driveway is showing its age, don’t wait for small problems to turn into major expenses. Recognizing the signs early and working with a trusted contractor can save you time, money, and stress.
Need a professional opinion?
Schedule a free estimate with J. Perry Paving today.